did you actually read the first page/any of my posts?



please...please...please tell me you know who the Inklings were.....

well if u read the 1st part i was the FIRST person to mention the message. so u should really stop flaming me

I wasn't flaming, I was pointing out that you weren't the only one who had discussed the message



did you not see that whole series of posts?

that only 4 posts u realize that? and u said about me not reading the early posts, well im the 1 that brought up the message. and the shit about ur dad doesnt prove ANYTHING. maybe if u said he was a pastor it would, but not a tolkien scholar or science professor, unless u said professor at a bible college.

dude cool it...your the moderator here.....since my Dad has a book coming out this year on Lewis and Tolkien, and teaches classes every year on them and since Ive been reading them myself since Kindergarten, I think I know about the books.....and the message...if you didn't notice all the posts I quoted are about the message of the books, and were all before your post. Kerm, why don't you close this topic.


EDIT:
===
granted the computer science professor part has nothing to do with CS Lewis, I was just telling you what his job was....the Tolkien scholar part was the important part....you do know who the Inklings were right? anyway I'll be glad to debate this with via Email or PM, although there isn't much to debate since we both know the message in the books is about Christianity....I also suggest you read those posts I quoted

Yes, before another flaming issue starts.

i suggest u shut up cuz i said most the ppl, not all and not u, y do all the ppl here try to fight all the posts on here?

BTW:The Inklings were literary enthusiasts who praised the value of narrative in fiction, and encouraged the writing of fantasy. Christian values are also notably reflected in their work, though there were atheists and Anthroposophists among the members of the discussion group. Contrary to what has been said about the Inklings, it was not an exclusive Christian club.

CLOSED

okay, patl411 and I made our peace, so he opened the topic back up....lets get back on topic

About time.
Is it just me, or was the ice scene a part of the book or was it just added for effect? I don't recall ever reading about that in the book.

Just saw this. TEH AWESOME. I was very impressed, esp with the visual effects. And yes, you're right about the added scene.

the whole chase scene from Beaverdam to the Stone Table is changed, but it didn't change the message, and made it better cinematically.

Exactly. I thought that overall they culled the scenes for the movie fairly well and didn't leave out anything / add anything too significant.

That it did. The Table scene made it more interesting I think.

Aye, you mean the sacrifice scene? He didn't put that in the book?

Did he? I don't recall. But then, I haven't read it in about 4-5 years.

Yeah, same here.

I don't think so. IT might just not have gone into details about the actual sacrifice, which was what made the movie scene more noticeable.

Oh, that sounds about right. My caf was playing the movie today, which of course they got legally...

As always.

They had the same thing with Harry Potter IV.
Edit:
30,000th Post!!