Login [Register]
Don't have an account? Register now to chat, post, use our tools, and much more.
[Review] Minecraft: A Freebuilder's Perspective
Published by KermMartian on June 3, 2011 at 3:30:32 PM CST | Discuss this article (52)

Over the past year or more, more and more Cemetechians have been discussing the building/RPG game Minecraft, a Java game in which players mine for resources, build structures and towns above and below ground, avoid death from monsters, and even build large-scale circuits. Up until this week, I had resisted playing the game on principle, both to avoid yet another drain on my free time, and to show my loyalty to Cemetech's pet project, Freebuild. Unfortunately, at the generous prompting of rcfreak0 and the persistence of my good friend ElderofMagic, I finally gave the game a try this week, and as is common with me and new games, I was immediately hooked.

If you have been living under a rock and are not familiar with Minecraft, it's a singleplayer and multiplayer building game where the world is an infinite expanse of cubes. The ground is cubes of dirt and rock and cubical tress and pixelated animals, under the ground are cubes of rock and goal and gold and diamond and a peculiar substance called redstone, the clouds are pixelated, and even the spiders and skeletons and zombies that appear every game night trying to kill you are pixelated. Your goal is three-fold: avoid being killed, mine resources, and use them to create awesome builds. To start in with the comparisons, the Freebuild concept follows only the last of those unless you're playing a Deathmatch game, in which the first and last apply. I feel that this is a point for both games. Freebuild allows you to build arbitrarily complex structures with no need to get blocks before you can use blocks, and allows you to scale, rotate, nudge, and rearrange blocks to your heart's content. Minecraft (unless you're hacking or an admin giving yourself freebies) forces you to find and collect things before you can use them, limiting the size of your structures and items you can create to what you can find. Tools must be created to mine resources better or faster, and tools degrade over time and are eventually destroyed. Finally, since everything in the game is a cube of the same size, the controls are very simple, as no rotation, scaling, or nudging is possible or necessary.

Minecraft has a bunch of the things I had always wished I could put into Freebuild, especially circuits and trains. The minecart system in Minecraft is fun to work with in my early experiences, but still leaves me wanting more, as it is constrained to the same cubic grid of the rest of the game. The redstone circuitry, though slow and requiring huge spaces to build anything useful, is quite powerful and intuitive, and I feel is a great tool to inspire aspiring electrical engineers. I'm looking forward to exploring these parts of Minecraft more than the building features, and comparing them to the vehicle system in Freebuild. Of course, the Freebuild vehicles work on a real physics engine, and all the complexities that that brings, a positive in terms of all the extra power, features, and realism, but a huge negative for development time. Freebuild has dynamic things like switches and movers, but they don't have the same connectivity that Minecraft's Redstone incorporates.

My overall impression is that Minecraft has a lot of potential, and is clearly extremely addictive, but has plenty of shortcomings as well. On every server that I've visited, players universally curse the name of Notch, and in my opinion with good reason. Although clearly he is a relatively competent coder to have gotten the game to its current stage of popularity and completion, the game has its fair share of bugs, lag, and inefficiencies, in no small part thanks to the fact that it is written entirely in Java. Freebuild wins as a native C++ program with ASM components in its rendering engine, and though it's certainly slower to code and debug C++ than Java, the speed increases are enormous. If Freebuild could achieve builds as large as some of the worlds I've visited in Minecraft without lag, and could provide for a lot more blocks placed with no stretching and no lag, I think it will become a serious competitor to Minecraft.

Please feel free to share your own thoughts and feedback on Minecraft, and on Minecraft in terms of Freebuild.


Four of the five towers of the above-ground portion of my Evocat.us empire in Minecraft.

Permalink
2011 Articles
January 2011 January 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» First globalCALCnet (gCn) Successes published January 3, 2011 by KermMartian
» gCn-Enabled TI-83+ Calculator Joins IRC published January 6, 2011 by KermMartian
» 178 Minutes of Downtime published January 10, 2011 by KermMartian
» CALCnet Chat! v0.9 Beta published January 14, 2011 by KermMartian
» gCn Client v0.8 Beta; Online Calculators Rejoice published January 16, 2011 by KermMartian
» [CALCnet] Obliterate, a Scorched-Earth Multiplayer Game published January 20, 2011 by KermMartian
» CALCnet Chat! v1.0: IM and IRC for Calculators published January 28, 2011 by KermMartian

February 2011 February 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» Stats: 40K and More; Awards; Latest Projects published February 5, 2011 by KermMartian
» GlobalCALCnet "$10 Bridge", gCn 1.0 Near Completion published February 9, 2011 by KermMartian
» Internet + Calculators: Introducing gCn 1.0 published February 11, 2011 by KermMartian
» globalCALCnet Slashdotted, Obliterate Progress published February 22, 2011 by KermMartian
» Obliterate v1.0 Beta: AIs and More published February 28, 2011 by KermMartian

March 2011 March 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» Casio Prizm: Why TI Calc Coders Should Abandon the Nspire CX published March 6, 2011 by KermMartian
» Obliterate v1.0: Scorched Earth for Your Calc published March 7, 2011 by KermMartian
» FreeBuild Project continues under Torque 3D published March 10, 2011 by elfprince13
» First Direct USB gCn Successes published March 15, 2011 by KermMartian
» Cemetech Goes on a Retreat published March 21, 2011 by KermMartian
» Doors CS 7.2 Beta 1: DUSB gCn published March 22, 2011 by KermMartian
» Benumbered v2.0 published March 31, 2011 by KermMartian
» Presenting "Cemetech Retro" published March 31, 2011 by KermMartian

April 2011 April 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» Half a Year of HCWP published April 6, 2011 by KermMartian
» One Hundred Fifty Thousand Posts published April 8, 2011 by KermMartian
» Staff Page, Promotions, Prizm Gaming Begins published April 16, 2011 by KermMartian

May 2011 May 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» Cemetech Advances Casio Prizm Coding published May 2, 2011 by KermMartian
» URL Shortener: Cemete.ch published May 16, 2011 by KermMartian
» Resurrected: PartyMode 2.0 published May 17, 2011 by KermMartian
» [Prizm] Obliterate Beta 1 published May 24, 2011 by KermMartian

June 2011 June 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» Nspire Saga: TI Reaches Out published June 2, 2011 by KermMartian
» [Review] Minecraft: A Freebuilder's Perspective published June 3, 2011 by KermMartian
» Introducing Gossamer 1.0: A Calculator Web Browser published June 9, 2011 by KermMartian
» Gossamer 1.0 & Doors CS 7.2 Beta 2: Web Browsing published June 14, 2011 by KermMartian

July 2011 July 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» Gossamer 1.0 Gains Notoriety; Project Updates published July 25, 2011 by KermMartian

August 2011 August 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» The Cemetech Prizm SDK v0.2 published August 11, 2011 by KermMartian
» Spiffy Cemetech Prizm Skins published August 13, 2011 by KermMartian
» Upcoming: Sandpaper FTP Client published August 17, 2011 by KermMartian
» Cemetech Goes to Space published August 21, 2011 by KermMartian
» GPS2KML published August 22, 2011 by KermMartian
» Cemetech's New Focus; Hurricane Irene published August 28, 2011 by KermMartian

September 2011 September 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» On The Casio Prizm and Link Port Hacks published September 4, 2011 by KermMartian
» [Prizm] Obliterate 1.0 published September 7, 2011 by KermMartian
» Back To School 2011: Cemetech's Calculator Guide published September 9, 2011 by KermMartian

October 2011 October 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» Latest Cemetech Prizm Projects, SourceCoder Prizm Support published October 8, 2011 by KermMartian
» Have Calc, Will Program: One Year Later published October 12, 2011 by KermMartian
» Play [Games] on Your TI-83+/SE or TI-84+/SE published October 21, 2011 by KermMartian
» Casio Prizm OS 1.03 Released published October 21, 2011 by JosJuice

November 2011 November 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» Social Media: Connect with Cemetech! published November 8, 2011 by KermMartian
» Cemetech Contest #8: Arcade Games published November 20, 2011 by KermMartian
» [Prizm] In Progress: Tetrizm published November 21, 2011 by KermMartian
» GCC PrizmSDK v0.3 published November 25, 2011 by TheStorm
» Sandpaper v0.8 Calculator FTP Client/Server published November 27, 2011 by KermMartian
» The Doors CS SDK GUI published November 29, 2011 by KermMartian
» Floppy Drive Music with a TI-83+ published November 30, 2011 by KermMartian

December 2011 December 2011 [Back to News Archives Index]

» [Prizm] Periodic Table of the Elements published December 2, 2011 by KermMartian
» Contest 8: Five Weeks Left, Great Response published December 13, 2011 by KermMartian
» Door-Mounted E-Paper Information Panel published December 14, 2011 by KermMartian
» Merry Christmas, Happy Holidays; Upcoming Projects published December 25, 2011 by KermMartian
» Build Your Own Calculator-Floppy Drive Music System published December 30, 2011 by KermMartian
» ticalc.org 2011 POTY: Two Cemetech Wins published December 31, 2011 by KermMartian

Advertisement