DShiznit wrote:
Hitler did the same thing 70 years ago, changing the rules to make a group of people (jews) second-class citizens, so he could label them, round them up, and get rid of them. Granted, we likely won't be sending "illegals" to death camps, but we're on the same track, and I fundamentally disagree with it.
Illegal immigrants aren't second class citizens. They aren't citizens PERIOD. Also, you lose by way of Godwin.
DShiznit wrote:
If you read up on it, you'll find that the quota system that restricts immigration to this day was first introduced by Republicans. Hell, if you go back even further, you'll find that our whole system of immigration was born from racism against the Chinese in the 1880s, again, by Republicans.
Your historical knowledge of the racial politics of the various parties is broken if you think that Republicans (Abraham Lincoln's party) were the source of all racial woes in this country.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_Exclusion_Act_%28United_States%29
Quote:
One of the critics of the Chinese Exclusion Act was the anti-slavery/anti-imperialist Republican Senator George Frisbie Hoar of Massachusetts who described the Act as "nothing less than the legalization of racial discrimination.
On the other hand, the unions, a hot bed of populist and Democratic sentiment, were entirely in favor of it. Quote:
On the other hand, many people strongly supported the Chinese Exclusion Act, including the Knights of Labor,[13] a labor union which called for improved conditions for workers, who supported it because it believed that industrialists were using Chinese workers as a wedge to keep wages low and conditions poor. Among labor and leftist organizations, the Industrial Workers of the World were the sole exception to this pattern. The IWW openly opposed the Chinese Exclusion Act from its inception in 1905.
Tammany Hall turned the northern Democrats into the party of white immigration, but the most violently racist nonsense was still being spewed by the southern Democrats, and that didn't change until Reagan's coalition gave them a chance to party hop.